Skip to content
Manacraft Contracting Ltd. home
All articles
Flooring

Refinish or replace? How to tell what your hardwood floor needs

Dull, scratched or worn doesn't always mean a new floor. How to tell whether your hardwood needs a refinish, a repair or a replacement.

By Manacraft Contracting5 min read

A bright living room with a glossy hardwood floor, large windows and patches of sunlight across the boards

A hardwood floor that looks tired isn't always a floor that needs replacing. Solid hardwood is thick enough to be sanded back to fresh wood and refinished, often more than once over its life, which is why refinishing is worth weighing up before anything gets torn out. The catch is that not every floor, and not every kind of damage, can be fixed that way.

This guide covers how to read the signs, what a refinish involves, and what to ask before anyone starts sanding.

First, know what kind of floor you have

The two common types behave differently when it's time to refinish.

  • Solid hardwood is milled from a single piece of wood, commonly about three-quarters of an inch thick. There is usually enough wood above the tongue-and-groove joint to sand more than once.
  • Engineered hardwood has a real-wood top layer over a plywood or fibreboard core. The thickness of that top layer decides whether, and how many times, the floor can be sanded. Some can't be sanded at all.
A close view of a herringbone wood floor in warm brown tones
Herringbone is a pattern, not a type of wood. It can be solid or engineered, so the pattern alone doesn't tell you whether a floor can be sanded.

Signs your floor is a refinishing candidate

  • The finish looks dull or hazy, mostly where people walk most.
  • There are surface scratches that haven't gone into the wood.
  • The colour has faded unevenly where sunlight reaches the floor.
  • A few spots are worn to bare wood, but the boards are still flat and tight.

Signs it needs more than a refinish

Sanding fixes the surface. It doesn't fix a floor that is moving or damaged underneath.

  • Boards that are cupped (edges raised) or crowned (centres raised) from moisture. Find and fix the source of the moisture first, then reassess.
  • Dark stains that go deep, such as long-standing pet stains or water damage. These often mean replacing the affected boards.
  • Loose, squeaky or bouncy boards, which can point to a problem with the fastening or the subfloor underneath.
  • Deep gouges or cracks that sanding would only remove by taking off a lot of wood.
  • A floor that has already been sanded many times, until the nail heads sit close to the surface.

Often the answer is a mix: repair or replace the worst boards, then refinish the whole floor so the repair blends in.

Screen and recoat, or a full refinish?

These two get confused, and they are very different jobs.

Screen and recoat

The surface is lightly abraded (screened) and a fresh coat of finish goes on. It suits a floor whose finish is dull or scuffed but whose wood is undamaged. Nothing is sanded back to bare wood, so it is quicker and less disruptive. It can't remove deep scratches, stains in the wood or a colour you've gone off.

Full refinish

The old finish is sanded off down to bare wood, damage is repaired, the floor is stained if you want a colour change, and new coats of finish go on. It takes longer and makes more dust, but it is the way to change the colour or deal with damage that goes deeper than the finish.

A close view of the grain on warm brown wood flooring
A full refinish sands back to bare wood, so the grain and the natural colour of the boards show clearly again.

What a full refinish involves

  1. Prep. Furniture and rugs are cleared, loose boards are re-fastened, and nail heads are set below the surface so they don't tear the sanding paper.
  2. Sanding. The floor is sanded in several passes, starting with a coarser grit to take off the old finish and finishing with a finer one for a smooth surface. Edges and corners are done separately.
  3. Repairs and clean-up. Gaps and holes are filled and the floor is vacuumed thoroughly. Fine dust left behind shows up in the finish.
  4. Stain (optional). If you're changing the colour, the stain goes on now and is left to dry as the product directs.
  5. Finish coats. Two or more coats go on, with drying time between them. Oil-based finishes tend to give a warmer, amber tone. Water-based finishes dry faster and stay clearer.
  6. Cure. A floor feels dry long before the finish reaches full hardness. Keep heavy furniture and rugs off until the finish maker's cure time has passed.

Drying and curing times depend on the product, the temperature and the humidity. Ask for the numbers for the finish that will actually be used rather than relying on a general rule.

Questions to ask before work starts

  • What species and thickness is my floor, and can it be sanded as many times as this job needs?
  • Can I see a test patch first, so I know what the stain colour and sheen will look like on my floor?
  • How will dust be controlled, and what will be sealed off?
  • Which finish will you use, and when can we walk on it, move furniture back and put rugs down?
  • What's in the written scope, and what happens if damage turns up under the old finish?

Looking after the floor afterwards

  • Put felt pads under furniture legs, and lift furniture rather than dragging it.
  • Use mats at the doors to catch grit, which scratches a finish faster than almost anything else.
  • Clean with a product made for finished hardwood. Don't soak the floor: damp-mop at most, and wipe up spills straight away.
  • Keep pets' nails trimmed.
  • Remember that wood moves with humidity. Small gaps between boards in the dry heating season that close up again later are normal. Keeping indoor humidity steady keeps that movement small.

Not sure what your floor needs?

A floor can look worse than it is, or better. If you're weighing up a refinish, a repair or a replacement, send us a quote request. We'll talk it through with you and set up a site visit, by appointment, before anything is decided.

  • Hardwood
  • Refinishing
  • Floor care
Back to all articles

Tell us about your project.

Call or send the quote form. We'll talk it through with you and set up a site visit, by appointment, anywhere in Maple Ridge, Pitt Meadows and the surrounding Metro Vancouver area.

Service area
Maple Ridge, Pitt Meadows and the surrounding Metro Vancouver area. Visits by appointment.
CallRequest a quote